News & Events


Reasoning like good lawyers or bad philosophers? Why people fall for fake news

Posted in Politics & Society
Mar 28, 2019

This talk is part of the Department of Psychology’s colloquium series.

A talk by Dr. Gordon Pennycook (PhD), University of Regina, in the Department of Psychology’s colloquium series

Thursday, March 28
3–4 pm
Room 153 Arts Building

Free and open to the public


The alarming spread of entirely fabricated news stories—“fake news”—during the 2016 U.S. presidential election is a salient example of how human reasoning often fails. How do we explain such errors? I will outline two broad perspectives on this question; one argues that humans reason like good lawyers, while the other argues that humans reason like bad philosophers. According to the good lawyer perspective, reasoning is often employed to justify our beliefs and behaviours so that we might convince other people we are correct. According to the bad philosophers perspective, in contrast, human reasoning facilitates accurate belief formation but sometimes fails or is insufficiently engaged. These accounts produce very different explanations for why people fall for fake news and suggest different types of interventions against political disinformation. In this talk, I will describe my research agenda adjudicating between these two perspectives across a variety of domains, and describe in detail my work on the recent phenomenon of fake news as a particularly interesting test case.


Back to News Listing

Related Articles

History of same-sex marriage project among $1.3 million in USask research grants from SSHRC

Posted on 2019-07-17

Canada became global ‘destination’ for lesbian and gay weddings after legalization, researcher says

CBC Saskatoon: 'An outpouring of grief': Saskatoon mourns after death of therapy dog that visited Broncos vigil, prisoners

Posted on 2019-07-08

USask sociology professor Dr. Colleen Dell spent six years using Subie to bring light to people in dark situations

Saskatoon StarPhoenix: Taking the Pulse: 84 per cent of Sask. residents want presumed-consent organ donation

Posted on 2019-07-03

Telephone survey was conducted by the University of Saskatchewan’s Social Sciences Research Laboratories (SSRL) in June

Students visit Ecuador to preserve endangered language

Posted on 2019-06-27

Four linguistics students spent two weeks in Ecuador assisting with a dictionary project

USask professor helps preserve history of Saskatchewan’s Doukhobors

Posted on 2019-06-27

A new historical exhibit, multimedia installation and documentary film will open on June 29

CBC Saskatchewan: Majority of residents say Sask. is becoming more welcoming to LGBTQ community: poll

Posted on 2019-06-19

The poll was conducted by the University of Saskatchewan's Social Science Research Laboratory and commissioned by CBC